atra ([info]atrata) wrote,
  • Mood: chipper

FIC: Nine Adulteries, NC-17

Title: Nine Adulteries
Pairing: Er. Severus. Harry.
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Chan. Some dub-con, I think. Strangeness. Spoilers for HBP.
Summary: Obsession isn't all we have in common.
Dedication: Inspired by and dedicated to [info]switchknife. Happy birthday, love.
Notes: The idea for this came from an exchange with Switch in the draft comments of [info]nights_nothings, long since deleted from LJ but not, obviously, from my brain. It's, um. Not like anything I've ever tried to write before, and I can only hope it doesn't suck. Title from Ezra Pound's 'The Temperaments'. Feedback always more than welcome.
Thanks: *deep breath* To [info]tangleofthorns and [info]shaychana for early encouragement, critique and hand-holding; to [info]snubkin, my most loyal lurker, for assuring me this makes sense someplace other than my head; to [info]gattava for the once-over; to [info]happiestwhen for the final beta; and to [info]switchknife for the bunny.
ETA: I've posted a commentary to this fic here.

*

It's cold on Spinner's End, cold even in his heated robes in front of the fire, and his gnarled hands are shaking as he wraps them around his teacup. Severus hates the cold, though he tells himself he really ought to be used to it by now. But he's not. He's cold, and he hates it, and he has only his hatred to keep him warm.

He sneers and looks at Potter.

Then again, perhaps hatred is enough.


*

Easy prey, I told you once, I called you once, and you were, wearing your heart on your sleeve. I wonder what you'd think of me now, if you'd think of me at all, if you were capable of thinking. But that's ridiculous—of course you would. Obsession isn't all we have in common, boy, but it's a start.

A start. Let me show you a start. I can do that, show you where everything started. I have all of you, you know, caught and stoppered, shelved and stocked, meticulously labeled. You're my potions, now, and there was some debate as to how best to organise you, but in the end I chose chronology.

But no matter. We were starting.

One.
You're thirteen. I have you before now, have you at nine and five and seven months. Undeniably interesting, unless I'm confronted, in which case everything is deniable—particularly my interest in you at nine years old. I shouldn't know you at nine years old. Meaningless. We were speaking of starts, and you're thirteen.

You're thirteen and you think you're thirty, think you're subtle, think you're clever, think you're smart. I assure you time and again that you are none of these things, but the last thing you do is listen.

No, you don't listen. Except when you do, and on those rare occasions you deliberately misinterpret my words, and it's incomprehensible to me until I remember that you're a child, and all children are mad. Particularly you. Mad, as you barge into my quarters with a please and a pout on your pretty pink lips, mad as you press them to mine, wet and clumsy but undeniably hungry and I don't know what they're teaching children in school these days but this is unacceptable.

I try to push you away. Mad. I try to tell you to stop. This is.

I try. But the last thing you do is listen, and your madness is catching.

It's quick, this first time, your body soft and straining against mine as I stumble backwards. You push me into a bookshelf. The wood is hard against my back, and I think about that, focus on that, on the wood hard against my back and not on the way your robes slide from your shoulders, broken wings on the broken-winged.

You're too thin. Too thin, too pale, too sharp. Your collarbones will cut me open. I can count your ribs and I can span your waist with my hands and I do. Blood and fire and breath in my grasp, and I don't.

But I do, I do.

I'm trying to hold you away from me, trying to tell you to put your blasted clothes back on, but you push yourself closer and your prick is hard against my thigh, your breath is hot against my neck and you're gasping, gasping, and then I'm gasping too, damn you.

You're thirteen.

*

Severus stares at his shelves, his lips curled, and doesn't remember the last time his lips weren't curled. In sleep, perhaps, but he doesn’t remember the last time he slept. He tries, briefly, to remember, but quickly decides there is nothing less relevant. He doesn't need to sleep. Not anymore. Not now that he has Potter.

*

Sometimes that's my favourite. I have a collection, of course, a catalogue, a cross-referenced, categorical compendium, but that one. That one's proof. Proof that you started this. Proof that you always were a filthy whore, a wanton slut even at thirteen, and that whatever cruelty I inflicted on you was well and truly earned.

Proof.

Oh, I know what you thought. You thought no one would know, no one would notice, no one would see that your eyes gave you away. Your eyes, wide and wandering and never where they were supposed to be. Your eyes.

Blind, of course. But if the last thing you did was listen, you never even got the chance to see. You were blind to begin with.

Two.
You're fourteen.

You're fourteen and you're masturbating in the prefect's bathroom, not that you're a prefect, not that you will ever be a prefect. But as the rules of the universe don't apply to you, why should the rules of Hogwarts? They don't, of course, and that has to be why I stand in the shadows and watch you. Why I don't drag you off, haul you away, have my way with you. At the very least I should assign you a detention, but I don't. I don't. I stand and watch and don't.

You're still too thin, gaunt and haggard and pale, and you slide a little deeper into the water. Your skin is sleek and shining, and your hair is damp and curling, and your mouth is open and gasping and I can feel the ghost of your breath on my neck. I'm standing and I'm watching and I'm hard under my robes and still I don't.

But you do. You move your hand over your cock and I can't quite see it from here, but I'm sure that's what you're doing. You're moving and you're moaning and you're splashing and you're ridiculous. You're fourteen.

But you're not—oh, you're not. You're moving, twisting, working your other hand behind you and between your legs. My own hands fist in my robes, dig into my thighs, and I can almost feel you stretching around my fingers. You'd be soft and tight around me, so hot my hand would catch fire. You'd consume me.

But you don't, and I don't, and you're not. No, you're arching back against the edge of the tub, you're screwing your eyes shut tight, you're fucking yourself on your fingers, thrusting into your fist, and then you're throwing your head back and crying out, short and sharp and yes and crying out and coming and yes.

I make my escape, and it's as if I'd never been there, never seen. I'd never been there. Never been.

You're fourteen.

*

Severus takes the paper when he remembers to do so, remembers to care, remembers he has habits and patterns and routines which keep him sane. He doesn't remember how often he remembers.

*

Sometimes that's my favourite. It's proof too, though of a different sort. It proves you have no secrets, no shame, no stories to tell I've not already lived. I drained you dry and drank you down. You and everyone who knew you. And they were legion, weren't they?

Whore.

It proves your blindness, your ignorance, your childish immaturity. As the rest of us worked to protect you, to save your worthless hide, your scrawny neck, your—enough. As the rest of us were working, you were tossing off, unaware, ungrateful, unable to see that which was right in front of you, always in front of you, behind you, all around you. Always. Always blind, in a place you never were supposed to be, a place you never—a place I never was.

Three.
You're fifteen and I wish you were dead. It would be the least you could do, really: dying. After all I've done for you. Tried to do for you. Though you, of course, are blissfully blind to it all. Still a child, then, dealing in death and playing at soldier and haunting the halls of Grimmauld Place like you're asking for it.

And then you are asking for it. You're asking. You're surprising me in a bed I shouldn't have, a bed you shouldn't know I have, and you're shivering and shaking under the covers and the vibrations shake my sanity loose.

You're climbing and crawling and clawing at my skin, and I'm letting you. I'm letting you, I'm lying there, and the noises I'm making are the noises you're making and I'm letting you lick me and stroke me and suck me to hardness and there won't be anything left of me when I— When you come. When you go.

You will, of course. You will. You'll come—no. You'll go. You'll go, you'll leave me alone, and it will be perfect, and it's that thought which does it, reminds me I only want you to leave. I want you to leave so I shove you off my cock and refuse to acknowledge you staring at it, staring and licking those lips, staring like you want nothing more than to taste it again. Taste me again, but you can't. You can't. There'd be nothing left, and I can't.

I flip you over and fuck you.

You're fifteen.

*

Today's paper is strangely familiar, and Severus wonders if he's read it already. Yesterday, perhaps. He thinks he remembers yesterday. Perhaps—no. That's madness. Today's paper brings news of another body dumped on the Ministry's doorstep, another body stripped of memories, stripped of clothing, stripped of self.

Memories.

Severus looks at his shelves, looks at Potter, and wonders why anyone bothers caring about memories anymore, why anyone bothers caring about anything else. He throws the paper onto the fire.


*

Sometimes that's my favourite. Often, actually, and I should think the reasons are obvious. The sight of you straining beneath me, the scent of your sweat on my skin, the sound of your surrender as your body opens to mine.

I hate you. I've always hated you. But it only ever made you tighter, made you brighter, and I'm hardly one to complain of such results. Perhaps it was this one which decided me, all those years ago.

Four.
You're sixteen.

You're sixteen, and you've lost what little mind you once possessed. You might as well still be thirteen, for all you think you're subtle, think you're clever, think you're smart. You're still none of these things, and I still tell you as much, and you still refuse to listen. You were probably closer to these things at thirteen than you are now.

Now. Now you're adolescent melodrama given form, all hormones and histrionics. Now you're clumsy kisses in the dark, clumsy tongue against my own, clumsy groping in the broomshed. Your hands are sweaty on my stomach, on my skin, and you tear your mouth away from mine and whisper, 'I've never...'

You're such a miserable liar that it makes me want to scream, makes me want to make you scream. Makes me want to make you want it.

But I don't, I don't. You don't. You're a disease, an infection, and I'm a rotten, hollow core and I don't recognise my own voice as I utter the latest in a string of inanities. 'Me neither,' I whisper, and I'm suddenly as miserable a liar as you'll ever be, but I press my lips to yours, press our lips together, and it doesn't matter, doesn't matter.

Nothing matters. You're sixteen.

*

The next time Severus remembers about the paper, he remembers remembering. The morning brings more bodies, stripped of memories, stolen selves, and he remembers why he stopped remembering.

He'd done this. Potions and mind magic and the Dark Arts, and Severus had changed the world, memories made form. He is no longer an observer. Now, he is an active participant.


*

Sometimes—no. That one's never my favourite. That one's poisoned by insanity, inanity and absurdity, and I don't know what came over me.

Five.
You're seventeen.

You're seventeen when you come after me, hunt me down, track me like the animal you forced me to become. You find me and I let you, let you believe it wasn't the other way around, wasn't I who found you. I let you think you're finally everything you always thought you were.

You're not, of course. You're not. You're nothing.

You're nothing and I let you be, let you become, let you believe. I let you take me, have me. Let you think you have me. Let you ask the questions, let you feed me Veritaserum, let you think there are no ways around it.

I let you ask me what I want, let you—finally—listen when I tell you, let you let me. Let you shove me to my knees, shove your prick down my throat, shove it in and out of my lying mouth, shove it in and in and in until you're shoving your come into my stomach.

I let you think you're all grown up as you collapse over me, gasping and panting and sated and utterly disgusted with yourself. You are. You're disgusting.

You're seventeen.

*

He hates it, of course, though he no longer bothers hating himself. It was too many years ago to count, and at least he can remember that much. He’d done what he'd had to do, as he always had. He'd always done what he’d had to do, and if this had further steeped him in hatred, at least it had delivered him Potter.

He sneers at his fully-stocked shelves.


*

That one's not my favourite, either, though it should be all the proof you require. You acquired a taste for it. For me. For me, as if your lips were worthy of any piece of me.

No. No, you were never worthy, and that's what makes it. Makes this. Makes everything.

Six.
You're seventeen.

Yes, still seventeen. Seventeen was an auspicious age for you, apparently, though you're too blind to see it didn't treat you well. You're seventeen and you're thinner than you were at sixteen, at fifteen, at fourteen. It's as if you've simply been stretched, been stretched and pulled from both ends, and you're in danger of coming apart at the joints.

You don't eat properly, I say as you skip meal after meal. You don't sleep properly, I say as you sit up night after night after night. You don't bathe properly, I think as you wade shirtless into a river and splash about like the child you so desperately want to leave behind. You don't do anything properly. It's disgusting.

You're disgusting. Still disgusting.

This life doesn't suit you, this life on the run after that life of being coddled, being treasured, being worshipped. Hero, celebrity, Chosen One. Please. This life doesn't suit you. You've been run ragged, drowned and reborn, and you are in desperate need of a haircut. Disgusting, but I can't tear my eyes from your hair, from your chest, from you. From you as you emerge, dripping, from the water. From you. Reborn.

I should rail against it. Would rail against it, would rant and rave and run away. I would, but I don't. You stripped me of my sanity long ago, and there's no longer any need to pretend. So I don't, and you don't, and you do, and then your body is against mine, sleek and shining and straining.

The ground is cold and hard against my back, and your prick is hot and hard against my thigh, and your mouth is wet and open against my throat. You're thrusting, rocking against me, rubbing your cock against mine and nothing you do has any right to feel so good. I clutch at your shoulders but my hands slip away when I come, you slip away when you come, and you're left bereft when I push you away and stand. Push you away and walk away on legs you'd never know were trembling.

Trembling.

You're seventeen.

*

They're looking for him, now. Imbeciles. He hasn't moved in years, hasn't left or lived or changed his name. They can't be looking particularly hard. Incompetents. Perhaps Potter is in charge.

He likes that thought, likes getting the better of Potter once again—this time, without even trying. When he remembers that Potter is his, the bile in his throat tastes almost like regret.

Not that he would know.


*

I never tire of playing favourites, but that one is somewhat difficult to categorise. I drink it when I'm angry with you. Angrier than usual, overcome with the need to drag you down, drink you down, and the swirling mists of memories curl their way down my throat. It's easier every time. Easier to drink, easier to walk away, easier to drink again.

Seven.
You're twenty-three.

You're twenty-three and hiding. Still afraid, still a child, for all that you're a killer, now. Wasn't what you expected, was it? What you thought you wanted. You wanted.

You're hiding in a locker room, hiding from your press, from your fans, from your fame, from yourself.

I've told you not to hide from me. I've told you.

But you persist. You're hiding and you're masturbating, one hand braced against the wall while the other flies over your cock. You're hiding as the water tries to rinse you clean, as your hair curls in the steam, as you try to forget everything you are, you aren't, and never were.

As you try. As you fail, as I make you. As if I'd let you, now.

I curl my own hand around yours, meet your startled eyes, your startled gasp, and I still don't taste you when I make you come.

I make you. I made you.

You're twenty-three.

*

They come for him sometimes. Less incompetent now, it would seem. They come at random intervals: nameless, faceless sycophants begging for his help. Severus, they tell him, you should do the right thing. The world, they tell him, is out of control. They have statistics and reports and the laughable impression that he cares.

*

That one's not my favourite. That one's never my favourite. That one bores me. You bore me, still hiding and cowering and masturbating at twenty-three. Playing that ridiculous sport and wasting your life, wasting yourself, wasting away.

Oh, don't—don't look at me like that. I'm hardly wasting anything.

I've a project.

Eight.
You're twenty-eight.

Yes, I've skipped ahead, though of course I have you in between. I always have you, and I have you at twenty-eight.

You're twenty-eight and you seem to be confused as to which one of us is the whore. Not that it shall matter in the end. We both know the truth.

In the end you keep chasing me, hunting me, finding me, fucking me on dirty hotel sheets, stained with a million kinds of come.

You're no longer too thin, no longer young as you snarl obscenities in my ear, no longer fragile as your cock splits me in two. Your teeth are sharp in my shoulder and your hands are hard on my hips and your cock is exquisite inside me, stroking and spurting and stroking and softening.

You're no longer. No longer there as I turn over, finish myself off. Finish.

No longer.

You're twenty-eight.

*

Severus is civil, of course. He offers them tea. Firewhisky. Ogden's finest.

Their eyes are suspicious as they glance anxiously around the room. He can smell their sweat, taste their nervousness, and he looks around at his well-ordered shelves and wonders what exactly they have a problem with. Their eyes light on Potter and he feels his lips curl, feels his hackles rise.

They decline the tea and leave.


*

Sometimes that's my favourite. I'll admit I like to see you so debased, but your cock in my arse isn't exactly an unwelcome feeling. Together, I believe the word is 'sublime'. I'm almost running out, in fact, but my recent experimentation has paid off; I've perfected the duplication process. If I had you before, and I did, I have you in multiples, now.

My final victory.

Nine.
You're thirty-seven.

You're thirty-seven and you think you're seventeen, think you're immortal, think you're invincible, think you're indestructible.

Incomprehensible.

Nothing's changed.

Nothing's changed as you track me here, track me to this ruin of a warehouse, track me and corner me and trap me in the dark, as if you expect to win. As if you expect to stand against me as you stood against him, as if you expect to stand and win and make it out of here alive.

You don't, of course. You don't. You always were careless, and now you're—.

I was never alive to begin with, dead at the very same age. Dead as you sneak right past me, miss me entirely, show me your back. Dead as I step from the shadows, raise my wand, bring down your shields.

Dead as I whisper the words which damned me.

END
Tags: fic : hp : hp/other, fic : hp : porn, fic : hp : ss/hp

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 157 comments
Previous
← Ctrl← Alt
Next
Ctrl →Alt →

[info]eslyssa

August 18 2005, 02:27:08 UTC 6 years ago

Wow. I don't know what to say. That's... That was amazing. I'm going to memory that, and come back sometime and read it again, see what I can make of it a second time.

I'm not sure what to say. Not sure how to react. Except to say that you are brilliant, and you are talented, and that this is amazing. Disturbing, yes, but amazing. Very amazing.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:06:42 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you! I was pretty nervous about this fic; it's not exactly my normal style. So I'm very glad that it worked for you. :D

[info]eslyssa

6 years ago

[info]annephoenix

August 18 2005, 02:37:51 UTC 6 years ago

Very... different. I like it, but it's perhaps a little bit complex for a non-native speaker ;). Which means I couldn't follow some of it through no fault of yours - just my own silly, slow brain. But your writing stood out as strong and as fluent as ever. I certainly enjoyed the words and lost myself in the atmosphere. I felt little sparks creeping up and down my spine, which is my favourite fic-reading feeling.

[info]gattava

August 18 2005, 02:47:34 UTC 6 years ago

Hey, don't feel slow - I'm a native speaker and it took me 3 reads and help to actually get it. I can't even imagine how clueless I'd be if I were reading it in a non-native language.

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]gattava

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]gattava

August 18 2005, 02:43:38 UTC 6 years ago

Eh, I said it already, but I feel compelled to repeat: Amazing.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:09:54 UTC 6 years ago

Thanks again for looking it over. I added a few more hints, but I'm not sure they helped. Ah well. :)

[info]gattava

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]gattava

6 years ago

[info]_inzilbeth_

August 18 2005, 03:37:03 UTC 6 years ago

Wow. Just wow. At a quick glance this piece of writing looks as if it would be an easy and fast read, but it is anything but. Instead it is intense with extreme depth. I admire this style, so very different from my own. It is very powerful, very moving, and at the same time disturbing.

I am just floored by how Snape is keeping Potter around him in various containers like prized potions ingredients and no one who comes to see him is the wiser. That has to be the most intense and disturbing scenes I have ever come across. What makes it that way is that you deliver it in such a subtle way that shows this version of possessive and obsessed Snape as being quite unhinged.

I am adding to my memories, I need to come back and read it again as I am sure a second reading will uncover even more hidden details within this amazing piece. Incredible work.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:12:27 UTC 6 years ago

I admire this style, so very different from my own.

It's very different from my own, as well! First-person strangeness is entirely new to me, so I'm very, VERY glad you liked it.

And yes, this Snape is quite seriously unhinged. *grin*

Thanks for reading. :)

[info]legacylady

August 18 2005, 04:31:12 UTC 6 years ago

That was .....


... absolutely INCREDIBLE!! I'm speechless - well, nearly! Off to read it again.

And, BTW, I wouldn't mind if you kept writing MORE fics RIGHT AWAY!

:-D

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:16:33 UTC 6 years ago

Re: That was .....

Heh. This one took a lot out of me, actually; I've been working on it for ages. I'm actually feeling sort of bereft without it. But I'm sure I'll come up with something soon. :)

Thanks for reading! I'm very pleased to hear you liked it.

[info]fleshdress

August 18 2005, 05:19:00 UTC 6 years ago

I'm not a Snarry fan. I don't even know what happened to make me read this. But I did and now I'm crying. Not great sobs, just quiet sniffles. Because there is something horribly tragic about this. So much loathing and disgust and even worse, this huge uncertainty about where to direct all this nasty feeling.

The writing in this was lovely, there are bits I want to quote back at you, but I can't pcik what moved me the most. I think Snape watching Harry in the Prefects' bathroom, with the repetition of I don't was particularly effective - with lack of action becoming a course of action in itself.

Absolutely fantastic writing. :)

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:26:15 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you! I'm so glad you decided to read this. Though I am a little sorry I made you sniffly. ;)

And I'm particularly fond of that memory, myself, so I'm pleased to hear it worked for you. Thanks again for reading.

[info]viverra_libro

August 18 2005, 05:23:11 UTC 6 years ago

Am speechless. But heartbroken, and in love.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:26:46 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you! Switch is, um. Inspiring. ;)

[info]tangleofthorns

August 18 2005, 05:38:24 UTC 6 years ago

A girl goes to bed early one night and misses her chance to beta.

It came out spectacularly. I will say more when it's not 8:30 in the freaking morning.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 06:27:56 UTC 6 years ago

God, don't worry about it. It ended up taking me waaaay longer than it should have; RL kept tugging at me. It wasn't ready for an actual beta until probably 2 in the morning, my time. And, you know, SOME PEOPLE have jobs.

But I'm glad you think it turned out well. Your early hand-holding was rather instrumental. :)

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]hlglne

6 years ago

[info]dphearson

6 years ago

[info]ariadneelda

August 18 2005, 06:58:19 UTC 6 years ago

OMG. OMG the ending! I think you just killed me there. But in a good way. Yes. And having reached the end, I re-read it and suddenly so many things acquired a whole new meaning. Snape. Snape's mind. Harry. Their obsession and hatred for each other. OMG. What an intense, chilling, tragic story. Amazing! I loved how everything led and culminated to that ending.

Marvellous writing! I loved the clipped tone (not sure if clipped is the right word but I hope you get what I mean). I loved the use of dos and don'ts and all the other auxiliary verbs. Very powerful writing. Yes. And I can't believe I managed a rather coherent review.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 07:26:31 UTC 6 years ago

Now you've got me dying to know what you think happened at the end. I'm so, SO paranoid that what's really going on is utterly unclear.

But, um. I'm glad you liked it! I do know what you mean about the tone. Fractured. Fragmented. Broken like Snape's mind. Poor guy. Rather unhinged, isn't he. *grin*

Thanks for reading. :)

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]moshi

August 18 2005, 07:00:51 UTC 6 years ago

Whoa, beautifully done and very powerful. My head's spinning. :)

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 07:26:58 UTC 6 years ago

Thanks! I'm glad you liked it. :D

[info]pervert_bitch

August 18 2005, 08:23:17 UTC 6 years ago

*sigh*
I'm depressed but amazed.
I love it and I will save this...

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 08:52:20 UTC 6 years ago

Aw, sorry you're depressed! But glad you liked it anyway. ;) Thanks for reading!

[info]aubrem

August 18 2005, 08:50:19 UTC 6 years ago

My feeble brain is going to have to read this many times but I think it came out very well. I love mindfucks - nice job - great stuff!

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 08:55:25 UTC 6 years ago

Eeee, I'm glad you liked it. I'm not sure how well the mindfuck is coming across, but. Eh. *I* like it. *grin*

[info]platoapproved

August 18 2005, 08:55:30 UTC 6 years ago

I read this while Snoy was doing the final beta, and both of us were making absolute tits of ourselves flailing over every line. This is, in all hontesy, a truly amazing piece of fic. I don't think I'll ever really understand it, but I do love it ever so much.

So, yes. You RULE. ♥

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 09:21:44 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you!

I, uh. I think I failed entirely at making my point, but the fic seems to be going over well anyway and I'm having rather a lot of fun seeing what other people make of it. I may try to explain in less convoluted terms in a few days. Or maybe not.

Anyway, yes. I'm very, very glad you like it so much. I would heart at you but I don't know how. You get this instead. :D

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]rantipole_

August 18 2005, 10:10:07 UTC 6 years ago

First thought: (and I quote!) "Good GOD, this is GORGEOUS!"

I mean lines like "broken wings on the broken-winged" and "your collarbones will cut me open" and "You're moving and you're moaning and you're splashing and you're ridiculous." and "I'd never been there. Never been"

But this was about the time I began to think -- hey -- there's something going on here. And my brain engaged. (This is why I had to read it twice to "get" it -- I was much too distracted by the gorgeous writing to comprehend the hints at the beginning.)

But my point? (er, yeah, I have one...) I like it BETTER this way! I love it that I was surprised by the ending, I love it that I had to read it twice (which I would have done anyway, lips moving at my favorite parts).
I love being surprised by a piece, and then going through it again, and seeing all the clues that I missed before, (distracted), leading up to the inevitable conclusion -- and not just that. All those hints of Severus psychological state made it a much richer read the second time through.

Really Love This Fic.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 12:50:55 UTC 6 years ago

Eeee, thank you so much! I will admit that I was going for that reaction: The slow realization that wait, something isn't right. And then the WAIT. WHAT. *REREAD* at the end. *grin* I've been wanting to write a proper mindfuck for a while. I'm still not sure this one is entirely successful, as evinced by the many theories flying around about what happened, but I'm still pretty pleased by the reaction.

Including yours! Thank you. :D

[info]rantipole_

6 years ago

[info]rantipole_

6 years ago

Deleted comment

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 13:23:31 UTC 6 years ago

*blushes*

Thank you so much!

[info]happiestwhen

August 18 2005, 10:27:44 UTC 6 years ago

That ending is haunting me. Still. fkdlsfl.

Also, this is possibly my favorite line ever: Your collarbones will cut me open. *collarbone fetish* Also, I like the violence it suggests, the sort of danger lingering between them. Your language and imagery is so rich. I felt immersed in the moment of every section, just like Severus is. I love the repetition and inversion of the wording in the lines. It made everything flow so easily, each line connected to the next. And gah, I would quote more of them at you, but there are just so many I liked.

I love the way each section is so different, and I can't believe the first time I read this through I thought they were all connected in a simple chronology of a single relationship. *facepalm* It was the ending though that clarified everything, because once I'd figured out how to read that, everything else sort of fell into place. (And I'm still not sure if I've figured out everything.) There's still so much subtlety I had yet to discover in this, and no, that's not a bad thing at all. I love fics that mess with my head like this one did.

It also messed with my heart just a bit. Oh god, Snape. *ache* djsdfkfsd ♥

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 14:14:45 UTC 6 years ago

YES YES THE COLLARBONE FETISH OMG.

...er. I mean. Yes. I quite agree.

And. Actually. The original idea for this WAS that they would be one person's memories, like you said. I thought it would be more poignant, that way, Snape re-living someone else's relationship (Draco, I was thinking), the one he was never able to have. But it didn't quite work, and then I sat down to write and the first section sort of ... happened. So.

Anyway. Yes. I also like fics that mess with my head, and I think maybe this one is messing with people more than I intended, but I'm happy with it anyway. I think it's not bad for a first try at this sort of thing. Right.

Thanks again. :D

♥ ♥

[♥ is a new addition to my LJ repertoire. Fear me.]

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]acid3

August 18 2005, 11:52:47 UTC 6 years ago

Amazing work, Atra. All of it: the psychological study of the characters, the language, the seeming simplicity of the text, the complexity of ideas, the mind games, the shock, the seduction, the power of your writing.

Now I'm rereading this and wondering whether any of the encounters involved Potter at all or if they're all just potion induced dreams/incubi/some sort of magical clones.

#4 seems as if it might be a real encounter. But it might be wishful thinking on my end. #5 seems real enough as well. Then #6 must happen after Harry's death. Or maybe it's 1 through 6, or none at all. Or maybe I'm misinterpreting the whole thing altogether. Arrrghhh, my brain! It hurts. I haven't had enough coffee yet to speculate further.

Can't wait for your commentary to be posted!

Loved the following two lines:

You're thirteen and you think you're thirty, think you're subtle, think you're clever, think you're smart.

You're thirty-seven and you think you're seventeen, think you're immortal, think you're invincible, think you're indestructible.

Yes! Wow.

[info]acid3

August 18 2005, 12:04:02 UTC 6 years ago

Ah, *blinks at the title* Nine Adulteries. Of course. That makes it a bit clearer. I think. I hope I'm reading into this right.

*sigh* I was hoping #4 was real: it just seemed like Harry had no recollection of previous encounters in it. As if Snape finally encountered the real person and doesn't quite know what to do about it after all the "clones". "I've never . . ." -- "Me neither." *shakes head*

Arghh, now I'll be speculating all day about it. You're evil, Atra!

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]acid3

6 years ago

[info]murklins

August 18 2005, 14:03:54 UTC 6 years ago

I feel rather stripped myself after reading that. Haunting, wrentching, beautifully written. Not sparse by any means, but no extra words either -- one of my favorite qualities in fiction, as I am so bad at achieving that myself.

But it was definitely a three-read effort for me. And even now, I'm left wondering, which is not a bad thing, but a nagging one for sure. :) So there is a spell, crafted by Severus in his obsession and which is now rampant in the wizarding world, that strips a person of their memories, allowing the spell-caster to drink them and semi-self-insert, thus "making them flesh". (Only semi because they actually take someone else's role in the memory?) And of course Snape's project is to duplicate the pensive-type memory fluid that he keeps in his jars, so that he never runs out?

Or probably something else entirely. :)

So, um, yes, you should do a commentary because I would love to know just how far off base I am and/or see you identify all the hints ([info]blythely did a great commentary for her story King Tide-- I still remember her frustrated "BECAUSE HE'S DEAF, OK").

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 19:39:27 UTC 6 years ago

You, my friend, got it in one. Or three, as the case may be.

Yeah. Snape basically came up with some way to alter Pensieve memories so that instead of watching them, you experience them. So he's spent years hunting down people with memories of Harry, and now that's all he does, is live in those memories.

*dances*

THANK YOU.

But yeah. I will likely do a commentary. Although I will be sad, because some of the theories people are coming up with are amazing.

[info]djin7

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]djin7

6 years ago

[info]murklins

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]murklins

6 years ago

[info]cs_whitewolf

August 18 2005, 14:31:57 UTC 6 years ago

I absolutely adore the style of writing you've used here. It is just exquisite and perfect and draws you right in and ::angsts:: it was damning and beautiful and by the gods I love you for writing it! ::loves atrata::

Keep writing!
Peace,
CS WhiteWolf

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 19:40:16 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you so much!

And there's really no danger of my stopping writing. That really doesn't tend to work out so well for me. *grin*

[info]bogfrog

August 18 2005, 19:40:01 UTC 6 years ago

Beautifully written -- it was a bit over my head, but the prose was lyrical and quite compelling nonetheless.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 19:51:25 UTC 6 years ago

Eeee, well. I'm glad you liked the style, anyway. It was my first trying at being ... um. Strange like this, so. Thanks for reading. :D

[info]bogfrog

6 years ago

[info]noesnifunifa

August 18 2005, 20:01:50 UTC 6 years ago

God, I hope I've gotten this all. Ah, even if I didn't it was still beautifully, beautifully done. Besides, only the best writing can be taken so horribly wrong. :D This was just phenomenal. I'm still picking over the identities of the memory people and can't decide if you wanted them to be specific or not. *picks over more*

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 21:06:36 UTC 6 years ago

Well, the first few are specific. The last few are not. Basically, once we depart from canon, the people lose identities, because, well. I don't know who they would be. :)

It doesn't sound like you've taken it wrong, though. So. Yay! Thanks for reading. :D

[info]djin7

August 18 2005, 20:49:11 UTC 6 years ago

I feel compelled to tell you that as much as I love your Snape and your wonderful gift for the written word, very little of this made much sense to me. Heh.
Doesn't mean I didn't like it, only that you are clearly brilliant, and I clearly like my escapism...er, simplified. *g*

Also, I found myself a little depressed at the end. Maybe I did get it?

Cheers!

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 21:11:54 UTC 6 years ago

Uhh... maybe? I don't know! It's certainly not a happy fic, so *something* worked if you're depressed. I'm mostly enjoying the various theories as to what's happening. [info]murklins got it, a few comments up, if you're inclined to look. ;)

Thanks for reading, despite the strange. :D

[info]switchknife

August 18 2005, 20:57:59 UTC 6 years ago

I can't review this.

I can't review this yet.

Atra, you've upset me with this. It's brilliant, and certainly the most perceptive thing you've ever written, and utterly, heart-wrenchingly beautiful, and. You've upset me.

I feel hurt and nauseous and. You understand compulsive behaviour so well. Obsession. Yes. Severus gathering and gathering those memories, his harvests of Potter. How I would have. How you've. It shouldn't be this right, damn it, you shouldn't be so right.

Okay, I guess I am reviewing this. (Why run?) The style--my God, as if I can comment on the style when I'm--okay, the style. Original, yes, but not pretentious; it works, it works perfectly, skips time in exactly the correct intervals, bends the reader's mind to Severus' particular idiosyncrasies, which is precisely what you need. So. Style = perfect.

Content. (Can you see me pretending to be rational with this? Hello, dissociation.) My hands were trembling as I read this, and I need you to believe that, to understand that, and maybe you will. There are lines of startling beauty here, as you well know, and if I tried to pick out any particular ones I'd end up quoting the entire fic. But what gets to me the most is your understanding of possession, and how, in his need to possess escape possess Potter, Severus himself is possessed. How he steals from others. How he ruins--so many--for what he--he needs--

He's so very much like a serial rapist; he is a serial rapist (of the mind), and you understand that mindset very well. I'm really very upset here, and my God, I shouldn't be saying this, but.

I love you for it. For upsetting me like this. Because that's what a brilliant fic is meant to do, and that's what this is. Brilliant.

Okay. Must breathe now. If you'll excuse me...

[info]switchknife

August 18 2005, 21:02:37 UTC 6 years ago

Fuck. Uh... Maybe my review really doesn't sound as delighted as it SHOULD be, because I am, I swear, to get a story as exceptional, as marvelous, as this. But I was so shaken, and. You've got to understand. I don't often get shaken like this.

*attempts a weak smile*

*goes for a drink of water*

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]atrata

6 years ago

[info]syrenslure

August 18 2005, 21:37:33 UTC 6 years ago

Please don't be offended, if I say that I didn't really understand this. I had trouble following all of the threads and extracting a cohesiveness.

However, the style and the writing were beautiful - teasing, haunting. Perhaps, it isn't meant to be understood, or grasped at first read. I imagine I will be tumbling this through my head, until I find it again, in the future.

Thank you for sharing.

[info]atrata

August 18 2005, 23:37:28 UTC 6 years ago

Oh, no, I'm not offended. I admit I was writing for the mindfuck, so people would get to the end and say, WAIT WTF and re-read. I'm not sure it's gettable on the first read, unless I'd already explained what was happening (which I had, to a few people).

That all said, I'm very glad you liked the style and the writing! This is a pretty big departure for me, so I'm pleased that it's not being hated. :)

[info]moira_can_bite

August 19 2005, 00:46:25 UTC 6 years ago

oh wow. this story flows and is smooth and i can feel it. the end is upsetting but very appropriate.. i knew *something* bad had to happen at the end. but i absolutely love your insane!Severus. i love him going in chronological order (yes!) and finding "proof" and categorizing them as favorites or not. perfect.

[info]atrata

August 19 2005, 10:02:28 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it. :D
Previous
← Ctrl← Alt
Next
Ctrl →Alt →
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…